How the 1959-D Jefferson Nickel Became a Rare Coin Worth More Than You Think

The 1959-D Jefferson Nickel may seem like just another coin, but for collectors, it holds a hidden value that continues to rise. While there were millions of these nickels minted, certain features, such as minting errors and unique conditions, have made some examples highly sought after. This article will explore why the 1959-D Jefferson Nickel has become a modern treasure for coin collectors and how you can determine if you have a valuable one.

History of the 1959-D Jefferson Nickel

The Jefferson Nickel was first introduced in 1938, replacing the popular Buffalo Nickel. Designed by Felix Schlag, this coin features a portrait of President Thomas Jefferson on the front (obverse) and an image of his famous home, Monticello, on the back (reverse). The 1959-D Jefferson Nickel was minted in Denver, one of the three main U.S. mints during that time.

In 1959, over 150 million of these nickels were minted at the Denver Mint, making them seem relatively common. However, over the years, the interest of collectors and the discovery of rare, high-quality examples have led to a growing recognition of the coin’s true value.

What Makes the 1959-D Jefferson Nickel Valuable?

The value of the 1959-D Jefferson Nickel has increased due to several key factors. These include the coin’s condition, the presence of minting errors, and the scarcity of high-quality examples. Let’s dive deeper into these important elements.

Coin Condition and Grading

One of the most important factors in determining a coin’s value is its condition. Coins are graded based on their quality, with the Sheldon Scale being the most commonly used system. This scale ranges from Poor (P-1) to Mint State (MS-70), with higher grades commanding higher prices.

For the 1959-D Jefferson Nickel, coins that are graded MS-66 and MS-67 are particularly sought after. These coins have sharp details and a clean, flawless surface. Coins in these grades can be worth significantly more than coins in lower grades, especially when compared to the ones that were in circulation for years.

Minting Errors

Minting errors can make an ordinary coin extraordinary. Even a small mistake in the minting process can lead to a huge increase in value. For the 1959-D Jefferson Nickel, common errors include:

• Die Cracks: These are raised lines on the coin caused by a damaged die during the minting process.
• Double Die Errors: This happens when the coin’s design is struck twice, resulting in a doubled image.
• Off-Center Strikes: These coins are struck improperly, with parts of the design missing or misaligned.

These minting errors are highly valued by collectors, and some error coins have sold for hundreds or even thousands of dollars at auction.

Full Steps Designation

Another valuable feature of the 1959-D Jefferson Nickel is the Full Steps designation. Coins with this feature have a clear, complete view of the steps on the Monticello building shown on the reverse side. A nickel with Full Steps indicates that the coin was struck with a high level of detail, and it’s rare to find one with this feature, especially among circulated coins. A Full Steps 1959-D Jefferson Nickel can sell for much more than a standard version.

How Much Is the 1959-D Jefferson Nickel Worth?

The value of the 1959-D Jefferson Nickel can vary greatly based on its condition, whether it has any minting errors, or if it has a Full Steps designation. Below is an estimate of the value of this coin based on its grade and unique features:

Grade	Approximate Value	Full Steps Designation	Error Coins (e.g., Double Die)
MS-63	$10–$15	N/A	N/A
MS-65	$25–$40	$100–$150	$300–$500
MS-67	$150–$300	$500–$1,000	$2,000–$4,000

As you can see, the value increases significantly with higher grades, Full Steps, and errors. High-quality coins and those with minting mistakes are highly desirable in the collector’s market, and their value is expected to keep growing.

Tips for Collecting the 1959-D Jefferson Nickel

If you’re interested in adding the 1959-D Jefferson Nickel to your collection or want to see if you already have a valuable one, here are some tips:

1. Look for Full Steps: Carefully examine the reverse side of the coin, especially Monticello, to see if the steps are fully visible and clear.
2. Check for Errors: Look for minting irregularities such as die cracks, double die errors, or off-center strikes.
3. Preserve the Coin: Keep your coins in coin holders or capsules to protect them from scratches or tarnishing.
4. Get Your Coin Graded: If you think your coin may be valuable, consider getting it professionally graded by a trusted organization like PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service) or NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Corporation).

The 1959-D Jefferson Nickel is a perfect example of how modern coins can hold hidden value. With its unique features, potential for errors, and the desirable Full Steps designation, this coin is a must-have for any serious collector.

Conclusion: Why the 1959-D Jefferson Nickel Is a Collector’s Treasure

While the 1959-D Jefferson Nickel may seem like an ordinary coin, its potential value makes it a hidden treasure for collectors. Whether it’s the high-quality strike, the possibility of minting errors, or the Full Steps designation, this coin holds significant value in today’s coin market. If you have a 1959-D Jefferson Nickel in your collection, it’s worth taking a closer look to see if you have a rare, valuable piece of American history.

Coins like the 1959-D Jefferson Nickel show us that even modern currency can surprise us with hidden worth, making it an exciting area for collectors of all ages.

Guilderland Historical Society

FAQs