How to Find $10,000 Coins in Your Pocket: The 1873 Indian Head Penny & More

You might think that the change in your pocket is just regular coins, but some of them could be worth a lot more than you realize. Some rare coins, with unique features or minting mistakes, are highly valuable to collectors. This article will explore the 1873 Indian Head Penny and five other coins that could be worth a small fortune if you find them in your spare change.

The 1873 Indian Head Penny: A Rare Treasure

One of the most sought-after coins for collectors is the 1873 Indian Head Penny. This coin is famous because of its rare date variations and possible minting errors. Let’s take a closer look at what makes this penny so valuable.

Key Features of the 1873 Indian Head Penny:

• Design: The front of the coin shows Lady Liberty wearing a Native American headdress. The back has a wreath surrounding the words “ONE CENT.”
• Date Variations: The 1873 penny has two main versions of the number ‘3’ in the date.
  • Closed 3: The ‘3’ in the date is close to the adjacent digits, almost looking like an ‘8.’
  • Open 3: The ‘3’ is spaced more widely and has a distinct appearance.
• Doubled Die Error: Some 1873 pennies have a special mistake known as the “Double Liberty” error. The word “LIBERTY” on the headband appears doubled, making these coins much more valuable.

Value of the 1873 Indian Head Penny

The value of the 1873 penny can depend on the version and condition of the coin:

• Closed 3 Penny:
  • In worn condition (Good, G-4): Around $25.
  • In excellent condition (Uncirculated, MS-63): Up to $590.
• Open 3 Penny:
  • In worn condition: Around $20.
  • In excellent condition: Up to $360.
• Double Liberty Penny:
  • In worn condition: Starts at $481.
  • In excellent condition: Can be worth as much as $14,744.

If you find a Double Liberty 1873 Indian Head Penny in great condition, it could be worth over $10,000!

5 More Valuable Coins to Watch For

While the 1873 Indian Head Penny is one of the most valuable, there are other coins that could be hiding in your pocket change. Here are five more coins that collectors are looking for:

1. 1969-S Lincoln Cent with Doubled Die Obverse

This coin is valuable because of a mistake made during its production. The word “LIBERTY” and the date on the front are doubled.

• Value: If you find one of these in good condition, it can be worth thousands. Uncirculated versions have been sold for up to $24,000!

2. 1983 Lincoln Cent with Doubled Die Reverse

Some 1983 pennies have a doubling error on the back of the coin, specifically on the words “ONE CENT” and “E PLURIBUS UNUM.”

• Value: Circulated examples can be worth around $250, while uncirculated coins can reach up to $15,000.

3. 1999 Wide “AM” Lincoln Cent

In this coin, the letters “A” and “M” in the word “AMERICA” on the back of the penny are spaced unusually far apart.

• Value: These pennies can be worth anywhere between $100 to $500, depending on their condition.

4. 2004 Wisconsin State Quarter with Extra Leaf

A few 2004 Wisconsin quarters have an additional leaf on the corn stalk. This mistake adds extra value to the coin.

• Value: Depending on the position of the extra leaf and the coin’s condition, these quarters can be worth anywhere from $50 to $1,500.

5. 2005-D “Speared Bison” Jefferson Nickel

This coin has a unique error where a die gouge on the reverse creates the appearance of a spear going through the bison.

• Value: In circulated condition, these coins can be worth between $200 and $1,200.

Tips for Identifying Valuable Coins

If you want to find valuable coins, here are some tips to help you recognize them:

1. Examine the Details: Use a magnifying glass to carefully inspect the inscriptions, dates, and design features on the coin. Look for any unusual features or errors.
2. Learn About Common Errors: Familiarize yourself with known coin errors, such as doubled die or misprints, which can greatly increase a coin’s value.
3. Consult Experts: If you think you have a valuable coin, consider reaching out to a coin expert or getting the coin graded. Professional grading services can help determine the coin’s authenticity and value.

Conclusion: The Hidden Value in Your Pocket Change

You might be surprised to learn that some coins in your pocket could be worth thousands of dollars. Coins like the 1873 Indian Head Penny, the 1969-S Lincoln Cent, and the 2005-D “Speared Bison” Nickel are just a few examples of valuable coins that collectors actively seek. By paying attention to small details, researching common coin errors, and seeking expert advice, you might find a rare coin that could turn into a small fortune. Keep an eye on your change – you never know what hidden treasures are waiting!

Guilderland Historical Society

FAQs